Which menu items should you cut? How to decide what to keep, fix or remove
Sort your menu by how often each item sells and how much it earns per sale. Then fix, reprice or remove the slow ones, one at a time.
By MyDobby team · · 5 min read
Look at two things for every item: how often it sells, and how much you keep from each sale after ingredient cost. Items that do well on both are your stars; keep them visible. Items that do poorly on both are the first to remove. Items that are strong on one and weak on the other usually need fixing (price, portion, description or position on the menu), not cutting.
A shorter menu can mean less waste, fewer ingredients to stock and faster service. But cutting the wrong thing can lose you regulars. Here's a way to decide that uses numbers you already have.
What you need
- Item sales for the last 8–12 weeks from your POS: how many of each item you sold and the revenue from each. Use the same period for every item.
- A rough ingredient cost per item. It doesn't need to be perfect. Even an estimate to the nearest 25 cents is enough to sort items into groups.
Leave out drinks and add-ons for now, or look at them as a separate group. Comparing a soup with a soft drink isn't useful.
Step 1: Work out how much each item earns per sale
For each item:
Earned per sale = menu price − ingredient cost
This is sometimes called contribution or gross margin per item. It's what's left over to pay for staff, rent and everything else.
Step 2: Sort items into four groups
Take the average number sold across all items in the group (for example, all mains) and the average earned per sale. Then put each item in one of four boxes:
| Earns above average | Earns below average | |
|---|---|---|
| Sells above average | Keep and protect. Your stars. | Fix the price or portion. Popular but thin. |
| Sells below average | Fix how it's shown. Good earner nobody notices. | Consider removing. |
Step 3: Decide what to do with each group
Keep and protect (sells a lot, earns well)
- Keep them easy to find: top of a section, or where eyes land first on the menu board.
- Don't change the recipe without a good reason.
- These are good items to feature in your social posts.
Fix the price or portion (sells a lot, earns little)
- Check the ingredient cost again. Has something gone up since you set the price?
- Try a small price change, or a slightly smaller portion, or swap one costly ingredient.
- Change one thing at a time, then watch sales for a few weeks.
Fix how it's shown (sells little, earns well)
- Move it to a better spot on the menu, or give it a clearer description.
- Ask staff to mention it. A short "the braised short rib is really good today" helps.
- Post a photo of it. People often don't order what they can't picture.
Consider removing (sells little, earns little)
- Check whether it uses ingredients nothing else uses. Those cost you in waste and storage.
- Check whether it's someone's reason to come in (see the FAQ below).
- If neither is true, take it off, or turn it into an occasional special.
Example (made-up numbers)
A small restaurant looks at its eight mains over 10 weeks. Across all eight, the average sold is 200 and the average earned per sale is $11. Here are four of them:
| Main | Sold | Price | Ingredient cost | Earned per sale | Group |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken rice bowl | 420 | $17 | $5 | $12 | Keep and protect |
| Beef noodle soup | 360 | $18 | $9 | $9 | Fix price or portion |
| Seared salmon | 110 | $26 | $12 | $14 | Fix how it's shown |
| Mushroom risotto | 70 | $19 | $10 | $9 | Consider removing |
The risotto sold 70 in 10 weeks, about 7 a week, and earns less than average. If its mushrooms and arborio rice aren't used anywhere else, it's a good candidate to drop or to move to a weekend special.
The beef noodle soup is the second most popular main but earns $3 less per sale than the rice bowl. Raising it by $1 would add about $36 a week at the same volume (360 ÷ 10 weeks × $1). Whether customers accept that is something you test, not something you assume.
These are example numbers. Run the same table with your own sales and costs.
Step 4: Before you remove anything
- Look at the season. A hearty stew might be slow in July and a best seller in November. Compare with the same season if you have last year's data.
- Look at what's ordered together. An item that rarely sells alone might be a common add-on to a popular main.
- Ask your staff. They know which item gets sent back, which takes too long in the kitchen, and which one a regular orders every Friday.
- Plan the swap. If you remove an item, decide what goes in its place, or whether the menu just gets shorter.
Step 5: Check again in a month
After any change, look at the same items four to six weeks later:
- Did the fixed items start selling more, or earning more per sale?
- Did overall sales in that section hold up after you removed an item?
- Did anyone ask for the removed item? If several people did, it may be worth bringing back as a special.
Doing this every season keeps the menu working without a big rewrite.
Common questions
How long should I wait before cutting a new menu item?
Give a new item a fair run, usually four to six weeks, and compare it with other recent new items rather than with your long-time best sellers. Best sellers have had years to build regulars.
What if a slow item is a favourite of a few regulars?
Check how often those regulars come in and what else they order. If the item is cheap to keep and brings in people who spend well, it can stay. If it needs its own ingredients that go to waste, talk to those regulars and offer an alternative.
Should I cut items or raise prices?
It depends on why the item is weak. If it sells well but earns little, a price or portion change is usually the first step. If it sells rarely and earns little, removing it is often simpler.
How MyDobby helps
Upload the sales file from your POS and MyDobby's weekly report shows which items went up or down compared with last week. Ask Dobby "Which mains sold less in October?" or "How is the salmon doing since we moved it on the menu?" and you get an answer counted from your own sales, with the data and dates it used. When an item is worth a push, Dobby can put it into next week's social post plan and tell you what to photograph.
Book a demo to see it on sample restaurant data.